Monday, August 5, 2013

God's wrath and God's love

Sermon, Year C, Proper 13


Personally, I love that we have been reading the prophets of the Old Testament as we have done for the past weeks.  We will continue to do so for the next few weeks as well.

There is great power and emotion in the words of the prophets.  The language and imagery are visceral and striking.

Yet it is sometimes difficult to follow what is going on as we skip from prophet to prophet.  A few weeks ago we had Amos, now Hosea, next week Isaiah.  Perhaps the skipping around also leads us to wonder what is going on with the prophets.  And while the prophets often have overlapping concerns, the prophets all have a different emphasis and set of opponents with whom they are arguing, but we often do not get enough of the text to clearly picture what is really going on.  For instance, Ezekiel was concerned with the priestly class and ritual purity, Hosea spoke of Israel’s (in)fidelity to God with the imagery of husband and wife (and today, parent and child), Amos (actually all of the prophets) were concerned with social justice for the abused and neglected.

But simply catching snippets of the prophets leads to a sense of dissonance. The power of the language, which is often strong and condemning, may make us wonder why we follow this God at all.

Why read the prophets?
The prophet is angry.
God is angry—wrathful, in fact.
What is uplifting about this?

And the image of the angry God brings an uncomfortable question:  How do we reconcile a notion of a God of mercy and love with a God capable of wrath?

In trying to deal with what sometimes seems to be an unbridgeable contradiction, it seems to me that--sometimes­—Christians may err too far on the side of wrath or love to the exclusion of the other.

This may be an odd both/and to argue for, but stay with me.

I think you may know what I mean.  There are Christians who seem to take delight in the idea of others in suffering.  They at least seem apathetic to the suffering of others.  I remember, one night in Gilbert, I passed a street corner where a youth group was standing, shouting and holding signs up to the passing cars and assuring us of our place in Hell.  There was not even an attempt to offer a way out; which one might expect from them.  (Oh God! Where’s my fire insurance!) That is near the top of my list of “bad evangelism techniques.”  It’s not number one—someday I might tell you what is—but it’s close to the top.

I have heard Christians speak of wanting to see atheists burning in Hell, because “that will show the atheist who was right.”  I somehow think these Christians have missed some basic understandings of loving our neighbors as ourselves, and they attribute human wrath (and a longing for vengeance) to God.  St. Paul admonishes us to put away things that are earthly, and set our minds to things above.  I submit that longing for God’s wrath to fall upon others is a misplaced and earthly hope.

On the other hand, there are Christians who claim God is love and mercy with no hint of disapproval of anything.  I might lean more towards this view, because it has been important for Christianity to reclaim a sense of the goodness of the world God has made.  Yet, I am also troubled by this view.  If God gives an unqualified ‘yes’ to all we do, then God is essentially giving license to all forms of discrimination and abuse we see. That is not good news to poor and the oppressed, who often suffer for the sake of the comfortable and the powerful.

How do we reconcile a notion of a God of mercy and love with a God capable of wrath?

This question is why I want to stay with the reading from Hosea, because in this passage from Hosea, we have one of the very few inner monologues of God recorded in scripture.  And in this passage God has to reconcile those very notions of wrath and mercy in God’s own mind.

Let us return to the text.  After describing Israel’s abandonment of God, We hear God describe God’s tender care for Israel as though a parent caring for a child.  The language is evocative and heartrending as God says:
Yet it was I who taught Ephraim to walk,I took them up in my arms;but they did not know that I healed them.I led them with cords of human kindness,with bands of love.I was to them like thosewho lift infants to their cheeks.I bent down to them and fed them.
Can you picture such a scene?
Perhaps you have lived it.
The care for an infant.
The devotion to a life not your own.
Sometimes, the pain of separation.

God remembers taking Israel out of Egypt.
God remembers protecting Israel in the wilderness,
God remembers feeding Israel.
God remembers establishing relationship through covenant.
God remembers Israel’s turning away.
God remembers what once was.

God struggles, and gives thought to deserting Israel who has strayed so far.  Wrath and anguish, memory and love collide within God.  God suffers a contradiction.

Until God remembers who God is.  God speaks in the text again:
How can I give you up, Ephraim?How can I hand you over, O Israel?My heart recoils within me;my compassion grows warm and tender.I will not execute my fierce anger;I will not again destroy Ephraim;for I am God and no mortal,the Holy One in your midst,and I will not come in wrath.
Theologian Stacey Simpson Duke describes the passage this way: “This is not the story of the prodigal son who, having struggled with his own bad choices, finally turns and comes home.  This is the story of a prodigal God who—in anguish, heartbreak, and the fiercest love—comes seeking out the children who have strayed.”

God violently recoils at the thought of abandoning Israel.  And the components of the divine life, specifically divine wrath and divine love come together.  They fuse to each other in a new purpose.[1]  God will seek out and liberate Israel again with the ferocity of a lion…with a roar to which God’s people will respond with trembling, but God will not abandon them.

Beloved of God, listen carefully.
The simplicity of the Gospel is that God loves us.
The difficulty of the Gospel is the recognition that God loves all with the exact, same, equal loving regard, and so all are worthy of our love and care.  This is a powerful claim of the Christian faith--a powerful truth which deserves unreserved proclamation.

Our God is a god of love who has promised to stay beside us and never abandon that which God has made. It is a love deeper than wrath yet fired with passion by anger at the human capacity to injure others­--and in injuring others we subvert God’s equal regard for our neighbors.

But there is a difference between God’s wrath and human wrath. We’ve seen human wrath in the world. While human ways of showing power seem to be demonstrations of destruction, the imposition of will upon others, and the hording of resources, borne of malice and greed, God says ‘no’ to these forms of power and call us to a different way. 

For the power of God is love, a life-giving power stronger than anything the world can summon. The power of God is the power to bring about the fullness to which we are called to reach through the indwelling of the Spirit of God. 

All of the divine life--especially love, but also anger--come to the creative purpose of restoring the world which God has made--
to liberate those under oppression,
to mend that which has been broken
to call into being healing and peace where sorrow and division fester.
To bring generosity where greed reigns.
To bring forgiveness where situations are thought to be irredeemable and hopeless.

The deepest trait of God is that all else about God gives way to a ferocious love fused with a passion for all that beckons us to follow.  As St. Paul says, we are clothed in a new self which restores within us the image of Christ and our Creator.  God relentlessly seeks us, desires to recommit to relationships with us, invites us into--and empowers us for--the renewal of the world, which is God’s labor of love.  It is a fierce love that seeks to work against that which destroys what God creates us to be.  It is a love with a sense of urgency, drawing us to God even as it propels us into the world and toward our neighbors.

May you listen carefully for where God calls you to act in love for another.

May you may know it when a godly anger at injustice stirs within you God’s call to act.

May you know when it is your turn to be a prophet.

Amen.




[1] Paraphrase of Katheryn Pfisterer Darr.

No comments: